Posted in Book Review, Books I have read

A Time For Silence – Thorne Moore

Historical Fiction

I was introduced to this book by BookerTalk who has written a great piece along with the author Thorne Moore for the Put A Book on the Map feature which will be posted on Saturday. Now while I wouldn’t go as far as to say I’m a keen genealogist, I have traced my family back a few generations and for me the joy isn’t in collecting lots of names and dates, it is building a picture of the women (I’m far more interested in them than the men) and their lives through the facts I’ve been able to glean. These weren’t famous or rich women, they were mainly domestic servants who married men of their class and had lots (and lots) of children. My predecessors had a very different life to the one I lead but I like to think that behind the facts they had the drive that led my Grandmother and one of her sisters to take advantage of the times and push their way up the social ladder. In A Time For Silence we meet Sarah who finds the derelict farmhouse her Grandparents lived in and decides to probe what happened to the family in Cwmderwen, Pembrokeshire.

Sarah has her life mapped out in front of her, engaged to be married and having given up on her dreams to be a singer following the death of a close friend. Sarah is under pressure from a pushy mother-in-law to be, and when she takes a trip to Pembrokeshire she does a bit of digging and finds the farmhouse that her Grandparents lived in. Sarah has a romantic view of life and she is horrified to find that her Grandfather John had been killed ‘by person or persons unknown’ following the Second World War. Sarah decides she needs to know more and sets about interrogating her Grandmother’s sister to find out more. But the silence kept for so many years isn’t easily going to be broken by a nosy young woman!

The construct of this book is particularly brilliant because we hear from Gwen about life in the remote farmhouse, about her marriage, her father and sister and her children through her eyes from the time she sets foot in Cwmderwen. We know what happens there while we watch Sarah follow blind alleys and incorrect assumptions in the future. Gwen’s story is easily the most captivating made even more shocking by her understated narrative. A book that so accurately evokes a time eloquently capturing the unwritten rules that governed generations which from a contemporary point of view are almost impossible to comprehend. Sarah has no such compunction eager to knock down the walls of silence that have covered up the wrongful death of John and changed the course of the family as they moved away from Pembrokeshire.

Thorne Moore not only captured the time but the place is also bought vividly to life through her writing, with the little Welsh town and the Spartan farmhouse easily imagined both by the reader and Sarah, as having bought it as a holiday home she works to restore it to its imagined former glory complete with heavy Welsh dresser in the kitchen.

This was such an unexpected read, far more emotionally charged and the story in the past far darker than I’d anticipated but beautifully told, this really did have me captivated. Although I found Sarah’s story slightly less compelling, it is the contrast between the two women’s lives just a couple of generations apart that is so very powerful.

First Published UK: 18 October 2012
Publisher: Honno Welsh Women’s Press
No of Pages: 400
Genre: Historical Fiction
Amazon UK
Amazon US


A book lover who clearly has issues as obsessed with crime despite leading a respectable life

26 thoughts on “A Time For Silence – Thorne Moore

  1. How interesting that you’ve traced your family history, Cleo! You never do know what you’ll find when you go on that journey. And the book sounds fascinating. I do like different timelines like that, when they’re done well. They can give you such an interesting perspective, I think. Glad you enjoyed this.


    1. Although it would have been wonderful to find someone exciting I do love thinking about the women in my family whose names and dates I know – some of those on the wider branches were brave enough to emigrate from Essex to Australia which back in the late nineteenth century showed a certain amount of grit!
      Thorne Moore used an unusual technique in her dual time-line as the reader understood far more than the amateur detective which made for some additional tension…

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Intriguing – we tend to forget that crime went on as usual even in the war years. And, ooh, a nice trip to Pembrokeshire for Easter sounds just the ticket! I shall pack my suitcase and be waiting at the station…


  3. Hi Cleo,

    I have traced the very basics of my family tree and found myself captivated by the life in service of many of my great aunts and indeed my grandmother herself, before her marriage. In fact, one of my great aunts who never married was, until the day she died in her late 80s, still ‘companion’ to a member of the same family she had been in service to for all of her life.

    I also have one of Thorne Moore’s other books on my ‘Want To Read’ list. “Motherlove” sounds just as intriguing and socially demanding as “A Time For Silence”, which is also heading for my TBR pile.

    Thanks for sharing such a thoughtful review 🙂



    1. It is hard to imagine those young girls going off to live with other families at the age of 14 or so isn’t it? I’m not sure I’d have had the aptitude for a life in service. My Grandmother was the first of her family to go to night school while working at a publishers to learn short-hand and other secretarial skills but her mother was in service until she married (and then had a baby three months later!!)


    2. I got so excited about the family stuff that I forgot the book – I’m adding Thorne Moore’s other books to the wishlist and will be reading Motherlove next – I thoroughly recommend A Time For Silence, so far my unexpected hit of the year!


Leave a Reply, I love hearing what you have to say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.