Posted in Book Review, Books I have read, Five Star Reads

The Long Drop – Denise Mina

Crime Fiction 5*s
Crime Fiction

This is the story of Peter Manuel, not a recreation of his crimes scrawled baldly across the page but a nuanced look at the man, both behind the vile acts he perpetrated and the one that he was in his own mind. In Peter’s head there was still the possibility to be another Peter, the one who was a writer and was famous for something other than burglarising, vandalising and raping. When he met the long drop (the method used for hanging in Scotland) he wasn’t the other Peter though, he was the man who wasn’t as clever as he thought he was.

Denise Mina has created a night Peter spent with the father of one of his victims. A father, husband and brother-in-law to three women who didn’t live to say what their last night was like but William Watt wants to know, particularly as he was arrested for the crimes himself, and so his lawyer Laurence Dowdall, having secured Manuel’s agreement, accompanies the men on a meeting in a restaurant one wintry Glaswegian night in 1957. Laurence Dowdall leaves the two men to it and they spend the entire night drinking, visiting clubs before finally winding up drinking a cup of tea in a car outside Manuel’s house, his mother a mere shadow behind the curtains.

The nuanced and assured storytelling is gripping with details oozing out of each sentence, not just about the crimes but about the characters, the essence of the lives they lived and the Glasgow of that age before the slums were cleared and Glasgow was cleaned up. It tells the story of a whole community which had violence running through it. The men jostling for position, just as Manuel and William Watt did in the pub, desperate to hold prime position, not to be outdone by lesser men. Being hard was what it was all about and the men who both protected and beat their women with fierce pride.

Of course we do learn about Manuel’s crimes too in a similar fashion, this isn’t a linear story telling, it is all the more captivating because we wait for the details; the half-eaten sandwich left abandoned at the murder scene, the empty bottle of whisky left on the sideboard for the police to find after the shock of the broken bodies left in the bedroom have been discovered. There is no doubt that Peter Manuel was not a nice man but we also see him through his parent’s eyes. One particular scene about their visit to the prison is one that I suspect is seared into my memory for ever, the emotions roll off the page in an understated manner which pulled at my heart-strings all the more for those that remained unsaid. I have a particular respect for writers who leave the reader the space to fill in the gaps, to allow them to put themselves in the shoes of a mother of a murderer without justifying the emotions she felt and what she might feel in a week hence.

This without a doubt is one of the best books I’ve read based on a true crime with this relatively short book being jam-packed with details which are wide-ranging. It did help that I had recently watched the television drama In Plain Sight, because previously I hadn’t heard of this man, although I’m now aware that for years afterwards his name was used as a synonym for the bogeyman for Glaswegian children.

I was fortunate to receive an advance copy of The Long Drop prior to the publication by Random House UK on 2 March 2017. This unbiased review is my thank you to them and of course the incredibly talented Denise Mina.

First Published UK: 2 March 2017
Publisher: Random House UK
No of Pages: 240
Genre: Crime Fiction
Amazon UK
Amazon US


A book lover who clearly has issues as obsessed with crime despite leading a respectable life

24 thoughts on “The Long Drop – Denise Mina

  1. Just reading this myself so I’ll pass on reading your review until later but good to see the 5*s. I don’t normally ‘do’ true crime, but love Denise Mina and Glasgow so this was a temptation that is so far proving riveting reading.


  2. Well, even when I’m “on holiday” you manage to talk me into books! Sounds great! I may not be able to read this one at night though, for fear the bogeyman might get me…


  3. This is incredibly tempting, Cleo! Mina is such a skilled writer, isn’t she? And I do like the way she builds suspense, even though, in this case, we know the ultimate outcome. Sometimes stories based on real people/incidents can be very effective, and it sounds as though, in Mina’s hands, this one is.


  4. There seems to have been a wave of good books based on true crime recently and this one definitely appeals. On another not, the cover is especially creepy, or at least I find it so.


  5. Great review Cleo, as you know I love Denise Mina and am holding back on reading this until I can literally wallow in it and it alone! My review will be nowhere near as eloquent and analytic as yours; I’m not very good at that side of things! One of your best reviews – undoubtedly the true crime aspect helped. There’s good true crime and trashy true crime, and I know we both enjoy the former!


    1. Ah thank you Linda – this book really did impress me and there was loads I could have said but I had to remind myself that other people may like to read the book for themselves! It is easier when you can talk a bit about the ending which for true crime I don’t count it as a spoiler and certainly not with a title such as this one! Good true crime is often quite hard to come by but I honestly think this was one of the best examples I’ve read.


Leave a Reply, I love hearing what you have to say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.