Posted in Book Review, Books I have read, Five Star Reads

The Murder of Harriet Monckton – Elizabeth Haynes

Historical Crime Fiction

I like reading non-fiction books especially about true crime, even better if they are back in the past; I think this is because it feel less like I am trying to gain entertainment from someone’s tragedy, and if it is new to me too, well that is the icing on the cake. The problem with some non-fiction true crime is that you don’t get a real feel for some of the characters, often the victim who is often dead before we meet them and unless they’ve been murdered for their own dastardly acts they can appear as nameless victims. It is for this reason that my preference for true crime is that which is presented as fiction using the crime itself as inspiration. This is what the incredibly talented Elizabeth Haynes has done with the story of The Murder of Harriet Monckton.

Harriet was living in Bromley Kent, she was a single woman of 23 years old; a school teacher and observed to be a devout Christian attending the local Chapel regularly. It turns out that Harriet was also around six months pregnant when she died from ingesting Prussic acid on 7 November 1843 and her body was found in the privy behind the chapel the following day. A sad end and one that because the vessel containing the poison could not be found, the only conclusion was that this had to be a murder. But who would want Harriet dead?

Elizabeth Haynes tells us at the end of this magnificent book that she has used the two inquests held as well as newspapers from the time to recreate the key characters in the book. She has done magnificently well. Every single person we come across works as an individual, and as a collective taking up their positions in their small town, they are at times terrifying in what they are willing to see, to acknowledge and to challenge. I cried for Harriet who had so much to offer but was sadly one of those women who was taken advantage of, and lost her life because of it that comes through whether or not you take the history that the author has created to be credible or not.

Bringing the forgotten back to life is the real triumph when fictionalising a real crime. No one was ever tried for Harriet’s murder, in fact once the coroner had finally concluded the inquest some two years after her death any traces of her life seem to vanish alarmingly quickly. Elizabeth Haynes states at the end of the book that she couldn’t leave this young woman without telling her story – and I heard that story loud and clear. In the hands of this undoubtedly talented lady, we are presented back with a fully rounded woman, with hopes and fears, with errors of judgement made and plans for a better future made – the facts that are contained in the recording of her life are fed into a story that can be taken at face value and read as an example of a life lived, in 1843, in Bromley so minutely were the details recreated for our consumption.

If you haven’t already guessed, I adored this book for the premise, the skill in recreating a life, the rich story that has been served up to the reader and the characters that leap off the page, The Murder of Harriet Monckton will most definitely be a book that will appear in the top ten published this year.

First Published UK: 28 September 2018
Publisher: Myriad
No of Pages: 437
Genre: Historical Crime Fiction
Amazon UK
Amazon US

Other Books by Elizabeth Haynes

Into the Darkest Corner (2011)
Revenge of the Tide (2012)
Human Remains (2013)
Under a Silent Moon (2013) – DCI Louisa Smith #1
Behind Closed Doors (2015) – DCI Louisa Smith #2
Never Alone (2016)


A book lover who clearly has issues as obsessed with crime despite leading a respectable life

20 thoughts on “The Murder of Harriet Monckton – Elizabeth Haynes

  1. This one does sound fantastic, Cleo. Like you, I like true crime, especially when it breathes life into the characters, so that you get a sense of them. And the story itself sounds compelling, too. That element of history interests me as well. I’m glad you enjoyed this one.


  2. What a fascinating story this sounds, I’m intrigued. I wondered how long Prussic acid took to take effect and whether she might have self-ingested it elsewhere (hence them not finding the container) before ending up in the chapel privy, but then I discovered that Prussic acid is another name for cyanide so death would be almost instantaneous. Poor woman.


  3. Great job, Cleo! I had been wondering where Elizabeth Haynes was with a new book and now I see – she’s been writing this one. Definitely putting it on my list. I am much more drawn to fictionalized versions of true crime. Non-fiction is not my preference. This one will suit me perfecting. It reminds me a bit through your description of Burial Rites by Hannah Kent. Not at all the same in that the main character is the one accused of murder, but a fictionalized true story.


  4. Great review! The book sounds fascinating. I’ve liked her writing in the past, and this sounds much more my kind of thing than some of her other books. Onto the wishlist! 😀


    1. As I was writing that piece I wondered how hypocritical it might sound, after all someone who recently died is no less dead than someone from one hundred years ago – but at least their living relatives aren’t around to see the books!

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I have this on my list and now I’m curious about it all over again. Wonderful review, Cleo. I don’t read near enough of this stuff. I’m glued to true crime TV shows. Makes me wonder what I’m waiting for. LOL


Leave a Reply, I love hearing what you have to say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.