The synopsis to The Things We Keep had me intrigued with a tale of a young woman, Anna Forster, struck down with early on-set dementia. It was also an opportunity to try and widen my reading in 2016, I love crime fiction but I do occasionally need a change.
Immediately on starting this novel I was pleased to see that although the subject matter is grim, the author has injected a fair amount of humour which also gave me a real sense of who Anna was, far more than a diagnosis that’s for sure.
Anna moves into an assisted-living facility where many of the residents are considerably older than she is, all except one Luke who is afflicted with frontotemporal dementia which affects his speech and language skills and the two become close.
We also meet Eve, a formerly wealthy woman who takes a job at the home as a cook and cleaner because it is one way to keep her daughter Clementine at her school. Both these characters are a delight but I particularly warmed to Clementine who at aged just seven, is forced to adapt to a whole new way of life. With a mean girl in her class needling her this is something of a struggle! This felt like an accurate portrayal of a newly single mother desperate to do her best for her young daughter but juggling this with her own change of circumstance, never better witnessed than at the school gates.
While there is a moral dilemma at the heart of the book which had me questioning my viewpoint by putting myself in to different character’s shoes, the characters are the ones who made this book for me, and not just the main ones. There are lots of touching moments from the elderly married couple who are inseparable to the old man who is grumpy and the one who saves a seat for his wife, dead for fifty years. Despite being at the end of their life, the author gives a sense of something more than a bunch of people with nothing to offer, the wisdom that they offer each other and the main protagonists was a joy to read.
I was drawn easily and effortlessly drawn into the world at Rosalind House which we get to view in the present, from when Eve joins the staff, and the year before. This device sets up the situation which underpins the moral dilemma and gives us a real sense of how fast Anna is deteriorating. In the beginning she occasionally substitutes words when she can’t remember the right one – sleeping clothes for pyjamas, by the end of the book there are more substituted words than the right ones, a clever use of language which avoids endless repetition explaining how bad things have got.
All in all this was an engaging, touching and thoughtful book which could easily have descended into a well of sadness, but instead, made every point you’d expect but often with the lightest of touches.
I’d like to thank the publishers St Martin’s Press for my copy of this book for reviewing. The Things We Keep will be published on 19 January 2016.
I must order this one from Amazon thank you for sharing your review
LikeLike
It was surprisingly well-written – one of those stories where the characters stay with you after the book is finished!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fine review as ever, Cleo. It sounds as though this is one of those stories where the characters are the main focus, and that’s great. I do like character studies. And the premise sounds interesting, too, as I think there are a lot of myths about what it’s like in these sorts of places. Glad you enjoyed the novel.
LikeLike
Thank you Margot – it is very much a character led story and with quite a variety to choose from. You are right and the author did a great job of reminding the readers that these were people too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like reading about memory loss (why? I don;t know…), so I have been wondering about this book. Does the content seem realistic?
LikeLike
I’m fascinated by the subject too although dementia is very scary – the content is slightly sugar-coated I’d say but not ridiculously so…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Though the subject was a heavy one, I found the book fast paced original and a real page turner.
LikeLike
Yes me too – I think the humour was well-placed and at the right pitch – glad you enjoyed it too.
LikeLike
I’m looking forward to reading this book. It’s about a sad situation, but there are always bright spots, places of humor, joyful things, even at such a time. I always felt that the people that surrounded my father at his care center were so gifted and patient and the other residents were so many things–sad, happy, funny, tragic, sweet. One sweet lady had been a nurse in her youth and she was still such a caring person. She had lost the ability to speak in coherent words, but she kind of crooned and hummed and she stroked your shoulder. I got the message and always enjoying encountering her. Parts of what you share here remind me of Lisa Genova’s book, STILL ALICE, which is told from Alice’s point of view and features her decline. There were indeed hopeful things and funny things and joy and love. My Dad, even when he had no idea who I was, smiled at me and I think was glad that I came and visited him every day. It was hard and a privilege.
LikeLike
Thanks Kay – my mother has dementia and although she can still (at the moment) hold a conversation although it is a bit hit and miss how much we stay on subject, but ultimately she is still the same woman she always was and I think it is easy to see dementia sufferers as without personality – this book really challenges that view. I think it is one of those illnesses for the main part is far harder on those watching than those suffering it.
LikeLike
I enjoyed this one, too, and having been involved with aging and disabled people in my first years in social work, I can attest to how real these characters felt. Their mannerisms and conversations rang so true.
Having the MC be a young woman with Alzheimer’s made this one especially sad, but I also liked her voice. She reeled me into her world.
I also loved Clementine!
LikeLike
I can’t talk from your experience but I was really pleased that this book portrayed the residents as ‘real’ people and not by their symptoms – I was surprised at how much I enjoyed this one!
LikeLike
Great review, but I don’t think this one’s for me. I find dementia possibly the most upsetting of all subjects. Can only hope they find some effective treatements for it soon.
LikeLike
I was wary because of the subject matter but it worked for me because the author presented them as people rather than symptoms. As you say hopefully they’ll be able to stop it in its tracks soon!
LikeLiked by 1 person
This sounds like a really good approach to a difficult subject, or at least one I find difficult to read about…thanks for sharing.
LikeLike
I was really impressed, it is one of those subjects we really don’t want to dwell on but this author handled it exceptionally well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This sounds and interesting read, I’ll keep an eye out for. I’m the same and sometimes need a break from crime.
LikeLike
I love crime fiction but sometimes it is good to take a break and see what else the book world has to offer – this was one of my more successful forays.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This one really seems to appeal to me. Must check it out; thanks for sharing Cleo.
LikeLike
Like you I do tend to focus on crime fiction a lot but this sounds like it’s a worthy one to try a different genre! Great review 🙂
LikeLike