Posted in Book Review, Books I have read

The Night Hunter – Caro Ramsay

Crime Fiction 4*'s
Crime Fiction

Sophie McCulloch, a lawyer, has been missing for 57 days having gone for a run one evening from her home in Glasgow and never returned. Her sister Elvira is worried, her brother Grant is suffering from depression and her mother is rarely sober. With he police convinced that Sophie left home with a married man, who has is also missing, Rob, her mother’s boyfriend has set up a page on social media to capture the last known photos of Sophie, taken at her birthday party shortly before she vanished. Elvira didn’t attend not being a sociable girl. Soon after Sophie disappears her sister defers her university course studying medicine and takes up a post as a nanny to a very wealthy man who she suspects has employed her to keep an eye on his wife Mary.

The Night Hunter is written from Elvira’s point of view, in first person present tense narrative, and follows the trail of not only Sophie but other missing young women whose cases appear to be linked. They were all young women who had gone out for a run, never to return. Elvira is an unusual character and several references are made to her appearance, her face covered in acne and excessive hair and these are in complete contrast to the beautiful missing girls. Elvira then teams up with an ex-cop, Billy Hopkirk, who is working for one of the girl’s mothers as a private detective. Billy is a clever but strange man who was probably the most endearing character of this book and with his connections he manages to open doors to the inner workings of the case.

The plot is good with clues about the girl’s disappearance slowly revealed, often through the police officer Costello who is in charge of the case. Although billed as part of the Anderson and Costello series, they aren’t central to the story with the main action taking place with Elvira and Billy as they roam around Glasgow linking seemingly disparate pieces of information together and following leads. The only mild criticism I have is that the views and descriptions of the other characters viewed by Elvira’s slightly unfriendly eyes makes them feel remote and less rounded than they could do. This is particularly true of Sophie who seems quite an insubstantial character despite her sister’s obvious bond with her, highlighted by the poem The Goblin Market by Christina Rossetti which they adopted as their own imagining themselves to be Lizzie and Laura. There is also a lot of misery running through this tale with few moments of relief especially as poor Elvira and her family seem to live a life of unrelenting misfortune.

The plot is good and truly chilling especially as the author ramps up the tension and the pace towards a gripping ending to this mystery.

I’d like to thank the publishers Severn House for my copy of this book in return for my hones opinion.


A book lover who clearly has issues as obsessed with crime despite leading a respectable life

21 thoughts on “The Night Hunter – Caro Ramsay

  1. Cleo – I think that’s one weakness – or potential weakness – of the first person narrative. It is hard to make other characters really feel rounded if the person telling the story is to be credible. But that aside, this does sound like have a solid plot and well-timed pacing.


  2. I agree and unfortunately in part due to the nature of the protagonist in this case it did weaken the other characters. The pace of the book was really good and the plot had plenty of absorbing parts to it.


  3. Hmm… I’m torn. On the one hand, the Glasgow setting obviously appeals, but on the other I feel I’ve read too many books that are kind of miserable recently. But I see it’s the dreaded FPPT, thanks for pointing that out – that makes the decision easier… 😉


    1. I put the FPPT in especially for you because I knew you’d be tempting by the setting. I have to admit I’m getting a little tired of unrelenting misery. I know I like crime fiction but I like my characters to get a break once in a while 🙂


      1. Haha! Thanks! Have I mentioned I don’t like FPPT much then? 😉 Though more seriously, the problem you mention about the other characters not being so well drawn is one of the problems with first person, I think. Of course, some writers can handle it fine, but it can be a weakness for others.

        And yes! I need there to be a bit of hope somewhere in the story…

        Liked by 1 person

  4. I’m a big Caro Ramsay fan – and the Glasgow setting always appeals, having lived there for 16 years (and Mr Crimeworm is an East Ended, having been brought up next to Celtic Park!) I’ve got this one on my TBR, so thanks for reminding me of it Cleo, I must get stuck into it. Much prefer her to some other Glaswegian writers, esp Alex Gray and Lin Anderson. Although Denise Mina is probably my favourite (along with William McIlvanney, of course – such a charming and handsome man!) Are you a “Weegie”, Fiction Fan? xx


        1. Was really surprised it won a big(gish) award (The Specsavers one?) Found the end convoluted and, frankly, unbelievable. Her first few books made her a must read for me, but she’s had a dip in quality the last few books. But I’m whizzing through The Telling Error (til 3.10am this morning – yawn!) so I’m sure you’re right. As long as it doesn’t go utterly mental at the end! I thought Olivia Williams was great casting for Charlie Zailer in Case Sensitive, but the Simon Waterhouse actor? Don’t know him, but, I’m sorry, charisma bypass!!

          Liked by 1 person

  5. Just popped back to read your review, after writing mine – you’re right, Sophie was a rather insubstantial character, I hadn’t considered that, I had thought we’d get to know her better when she was found…I was utterly convinced, judging by her symptoms, that Elvie had PCOS – I thought I was smart, getting that! (But totally wrong!)


Leave a Reply, I love hearing what you have to say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.