It is rare that a book tackles what happens after a murderer has been convicted. I don’t mean so much what is life like in prison for the perpetrator but what happens to the relatives, both those of the victim and those connected by blood to the killer.
Only a Mother really examines the aftermath of a crime and the ripples that it causes years after the murder was committed. Craig Wright was convicted of the murder of an eighteen year old girl when he was twenty and has been in prison for seventeen years, his mother has been in her own prison for the same amount of time, convinced of her son’s innocence she is now ready to welcome him home. Home is Preston and the locals have long memories and are an unforgiving bunch. Erica, his mother, is shunned in her home town, she travels to the next town to go shopping to avoid the stares, the taunts and attracting unwanted attention.
Luke is a reporter on the local newspaper, he is mentoring a youngster and is updating the locals on Craig’s impending release. Luke is at that point in his life when he feels the best is behind him and he’s following some diet with ‘points’ that makes him hungry! He’s thrilled when his article attracts lots of angry and sad faces, he’s getting recognition he hasn’t had for years.
Which neatly leads onto one key winner as far as I’m concerned is that this book is clearly written in the here and now. Erica has been on a prisoner’s family forum for so many years she’s become a moderator. Luke neatly gives his views on the millennials from his lofty middle-age and cleverly mimics the change in language of headlines over the years (we move to someone being spared jail in the early noughties to the more recent screaming headline ‘criminal caged for assault!’)
This is a tense book as despite the crime being firmly in the past, it hasn’t stayed there. In part because there was another murder very close in time to the one Craig was convicted of but he wasn’t charged as he had a watertight alibi. It is this fact that has Erica clinging to his innocence and perhaps the same that means the locals feel he has got away with another murder. Either way from a reader’s perspective, it is hard to warm to Craig although I did find myself having more sympathy for Erica. The book raises that dilemma – what would you do? At what point do you turn your back on your own flesh and blood? That’s not to say Erica doesn’t have her doubts when the fully grown large man is back under her roof and then another girl goes missing!
I found myself drawn into the small group of characters, the intensity of everyone searching for the truth but unsure where to find it. Erica’s furtive posting on the forum seeking the reassurance from her friends there that she is doing the right thing and of course she reflects, as mothers are wont to do, on the past – right back to the birth and what she could have done differently.
This was an insightful book that shone a light on a relatively neglected aspect of crime, the hurt that doesn’t fade and the need of some people to believe that all is not quite as it seems.
I’d like to say a huge thank you to Random House UK for giving me a copy of Only a Mother ahead of publication on 27 December 2018. This unbiased review is my thanks to them and the author for such a thought-provoking read.
First Published UK: 27 December 2018
No of Pages: 352
Genre: Psychological Thriller
10 thoughts on “Only a Mother – Elisabeth Carpenter”
I wanted to read this but got rejected
Seems like a great thriller… It is in my amazon wishlist waiting for the price to come down
This sounds like a very insightful look at how a crime impacts people on so many levels, Cleo. And the small-town setting really works for this sort of story. That mother-child bond sounds like an important part of the story, too, and that adds to the interest for me. I’m glad you found it so engaging.
Hi Cleo – this sounds like a fascinating story and an excellent look at the mother-son dynamic. Erica’s instinct to believe and protect is very strong.
It is interesting to consider how crimes affect the family of the convicted. The book I’m currently reading doesn’t have the family of a murderer (or not yet anyway), but it does have the family of a teen that has gone down the path of drug use, rehab, drug use, rehab, etc. The mother is weary and sad and just wants her life to be different. It is obvious that the hurt and sorrow is ever with the wrongdoer’s family. Wow. Not at all cheerful, right?
What a wonderful review! There are so many victims to a violent crime. This sounds fascinating and thrilling and I’m so curious to read the outcome.
Different than the usual murder story and it sounds like a good one.
sherry @ fundinmental
Great review, leaving me with a lot to think about. Thanks for sharing.
I can’t imagine the pain it must cause a parent to know their child may have murdered another person-you would blame yourself, even if you were the best parent!
Exactly you can see how this makes a brilliant premise for the story.
LikeLiked by 1 person