Posted in Book Review, Books I have read, Mount TBR 2018, The Classic Club

The Shuttle – Frances Hodgeson Burnett


The Classic Club Spin number 18 picked The Shuttle by Frances Hodgeson Burnett for me which was one of my choices of children’s authors who had written books for adults too. Once it was picked I then decided to investigate a little more – you can read my full post here.

So I was a little concerned about the length of the book and with good reason given that I only finished the last page shortly before leaving for work this morning! But I was very impressed to find out that the garden at Great Maytham Hall near Rolvenden, Kent, as inspiration for the setting of this book, and The Secret Garden – more of that later.

Great Maytham Hall Garden by Stephen Nunnery

So what did I think of the book. Well although it was long at well over 500 pages most of the time the story flowed along although I have to confess there were times when the lengthy descriptions so common at this time wore me down but there were plenty of surprises, maybe not so much plot wise but I found the attitudes given the time that this was written in 1907 far more forward thinking than I expected.

The story opens in New York with Sir Nigel Anstruthers meeting the young and fairly insubstantial, in build and character, Rosalie Vanderpoel. Rosalie is an heiress of magnitude and Nigel Anstruthers was seeking just such a young woman to marry with the aim of using her wealth for the upkeep of Stornham Court. Nigel meets the parents, the younger sister Bettina and the couple soon tie the knot. As Sir and Lady Anstruthers they set sail for the UK and then by train to Kent where Stornham Court is far more dilapidated than Rosalie expected. But since by that time her husband has failed to keep his brutish nature under wraps she is already on edge. Meeting the dowager does nothing to improve her feelings and it soon becomes apparent that she is trapped.

Many years later her younger sister Betty comes to find her. In the intervening years the house has fallen into even more severe disrepair as all the money has been spent on Sir Anstruther’s own entertainment. Rosalie is in just as bad shape, having also fallen into disrepair, her one surviving son who has a deformity being the only meaning in her life. Betty is shocked but a strong-willed and ‘business-like’ young woman who takes the house and her sister in hand.

With echoes of what would become the healing nature of plants and flowers in the Secret Garden within this book as one of Betty’s first actions is to hire a Head Gardener to oversee the many younger men to bring the garden to life. There are walks round the garden, descriptions of various flowers and a sense that this beauty breathes life into her sister’s soul.

There is also the inevitable romance playing out alongside the younger sister’s careful plan to extricate her sister from her awful marriage. This is a very modern woman who while approaching life somewhat differently given the slightly less rigid American lifestyle to that expected in an English village must surely have spoken to the Edwardian women who read this book at the time of publication. That along with a cautionary tale to those in America not to be taken in by a title alone. There is much said about what constitutes a married woman’s property what separating would mean for a woman not only in terms of her standing in society but that she would lose custody of her child. I couldn’t help but wonder what those women who were living under just such a regime took from this story.

There are dramatic scenes before the climax of the book which definitely allude to the particular power a man has over a woman, even a strong and clever woman, which while not in any way explicit was quite unexpected.

So in conclusion this was a good choice as one of  my Classic Club reads as there was much to enjoy within these pages that include travelling salesmen, hop pickers and magic wands aplenty in the form of a seemingly inexhaustible supply of money. I did mark it down by one star because it was a little bit of a slog in places but in all honestly I don’t think I’ll forget the many and varied characters I met during this read.

The Shuttle is number 46 on The Classics Club list and the seventh of my fifty choices that I’ve read and reviewed.

First Published UK: 1907
Publisher: Persephone Books
No of Pages: 536
Genre: Classic Fiction
Amazon UK
Amazon US


A book lover who clearly has issues as obsessed with crime despite leading a respectable life

18 thoughts on “The Shuttle – Frances Hodgeson Burnett

  1. It does sound like such an interesting look at that era, Cleo, and at the roles that men and women played during it. That alone makes the book appealing to me, even if it is a bit long and ‘slog-ish’ in places. I’m also curious, of course, about a book for adults written by a children’s author whose work I loved when I was young. I’m glad you enjoyed it overall.


    1. Thank you Margot – although it was a bit long-winded in places it was also fascinating and so although it is many years since I read those childhood favourites I definitely felt echoes in this book – the frankness about such sensitive subjects at the time leads me to believe she was a ‘brave’ author too.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Gosh, I am such a target reader for this book! A gardener and storyteller and UK lover. Thanks for the detailed and informative review! I’ll be reading this one for sure. Cheers.


  3. Ooh, I didn’t know FHB wrote books for adults. I loved “A Little Princess” and “The Secret Garden” as a child and this story sounds interesting – I shall add it to my TBR list.


  4. Sounds like you managed to enjoy it even if some parts were a bit of a slog. I’m impressed that you were able to fit in a 500 page chunkster – I was so glad my pick was one of the short ones in my list!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I didn’t know about this book, but I was so pleased to see your post, since I re-read The Secret Garden this summer! Great to see the picture of the actual garden that inspired Burnett. I also like your comment about a seemingly inexhaustible supply of money. That’s what I often think about books from this genre and era!


  6. I didn’t realise Frances Hodgeson Burnett had books for adults published! Great review. I’m pleased that you enjoyed it despite the slog at points!


  7. I have not read The Secret Garden yet but I think I should change that soon. Then I can pick this one up too. Your review us well done and I appreciate the resolve and determination of Betty to help her sister with such a disappointing marital arrangement. I am curious about what happens. Great job and thanks for sharing!


    1. It was good and part of my issue was trying to read to a deadline when I didn’t have much time – for all that it was a really interesting way to look at the differences between the US and the UK at this time and from a contemporary viewpoint.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply, I love hearing what you have to say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.