I have finally started Martin Edwards’ famed Lake District Mystery series with The Coffin Trail, the first in the series. The title has been chosen for the name given to the tracks which were used to transport bodies from the remote village to one with a graveyard. The symbolism of bodies being strapped to the horses for their final journey is one that resonates throughout this book.
As the book opens we meet Daniel Heard and his girlfriend Miranda buying Tarn Cottage in the fictional village of Brackdale on a whim while visiting the area for a short break. Daniel has tired in his role at Oxford University but it is Miranda who is the driving force behind the move, after all as a freelance journalist she can submit her copy from anywhere. Daniel has visited the area before, the last holiday before his policeman father left home to be with another woman and while there he met, and became friends with, Barrie Gilpin who lived in Tarn Cottage. The cottage is being sold for a song because Barrie Gilpin was widely suspected by police and villagers alike to have murdered a young woman. He died of an accident before the murder was discovered and his poor mother was shunned by the locals.
Meanwhile DI Hannah Scarlett is wondering if she can get her career back on track after a disastrous collapse of a trial compounded by even more disastrous public relations. She finds herself leading a new team set up to examine whether advances in forensics can solve any of the old cases. With a retired detective to assist and her trusty partner they begin leafing through the old files.
As Daniel probes the villager’s memories about Barrie, treating this personal quest he begins to ruffle a few feathers to say the least and Miranda is none too pleased. With some loose ends to tie up about his father, who died without Daniel ever making peace, who was on the original investigation the claustrophobic nature of life in a remote village becomes ever more apparent.
I enjoyed The Coffin Trail which was first published in 2004 for being a ‘real’ police procedural series. There were no clever tricks but straightforward investigations by both Daniel and Hannah Scarlet into what happened to the young woman who was laid out on Sacrifice Stone, it can’t be accidental that this was the place for pagan rituals. There are lots of characters within this book and of course being the first in the series, more time is spent giving these a background to be built on later, this gave the first section of the book quite a slow feel, but with solid writing and the fabulous scenery that Martin Edwards captures, keeping me entertained, I certainly didn’t have a chance to become bored.
Once the investigation gets underway it appears that the crux of the matter is going to be examining those old alibis rather than the more straightforward DNA results that DI Hannah Scarlett’s bosses were hoping for. And we all know what that means, yes my favourite, old secrets and lies will be exposed! There is no doubt at all that plenty of skeletons, of the kind that hide in cupboards, are rattled. As secret after secret is revealed the inhabitants of Brackdale will most likely never be the same again.
After really enjoying the characters of historian Daniel Head and the fairly level-headed and yet not to be pushed around, DI Hannah Scarlett I am now looking forward to reading the second in this series, The Cipher Garden which fortunately already resides on my kindle! I have a feeling this is a series I can trust to give me a solid mystery in a straightforward style relying on the writing alone to be the entertainment.
First Published UK: 1 July 2004
Publisher: Allison & Busby
No of Pages: 228
Genre: Crime Fiction – Police Procedural
Amazon UK
Amazon US
This looks like a good, meaty read with complex characters and plenty of plot. It’s on the list!
LikeLike
Excellent news Dianne – it is a solid police procedural and so I’m very much looking forward to the next in the series.
LikeLike
I enjoyed this series, as well as others by Martin Edwards. He’s a local author to me and has been on my radar for a while. His mum used to visit the library in my librarian days.
LikeLike
Oh how lovely to have the local connection Jill – he is very talented!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m keen to read this series as I do like his work on the Golden Age. Great to hear he can write crime as well as talk about others writing it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have his Golden Age book on my shelf which I must read too!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do like a procedural from time to time and this sounds like it has real depth and interest.
LikeLike
Martin Edwards is a very talented writer and I was really impressed with this one, especially as it is the first in the series which is always the trickiest to pull off I think.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So happy to hear that you enjoyed this, Cleo! Edwards is really talented, and I think you’re right; he offers a strong police procedural series. In my opinion, the series continues to grow as it goes on.
LikeLike
I got the feeling that now the characters were set the series will only continue to grow – I’m looking forward to reading The Cipher Garden soon.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sounds like a solid mystery read, and along with great writing that’s often so much more fun to read than something where the author tries lots of tricky techniques like back and forth timelines.
LikeLike
As much as I like to be wowed by clever writing techniques, it takes a great writer to keep you entertained without those devices – Martin Edwards is part of the latter group.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yay! I’m glad you enjoyed this since it’s sitting on my Kindle already! I did read a later one in the series and liked it a lot, so I’m looking forward to backtracking and reading them all eventually… I liked the slightly Golden Age-y feel, proper mysteries and clues and so on.
LikeLike
Haha yes it is a solid read and had a feeling that now the characters are set the series will only improve – and I did enjoy this a great deal. I’ve found recently that I’m far more impressed by theise more traditional types of writers than the newer flashier versions, they do have quite a different feel to them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Going to have to check this out. Great review!
LikeLike
Thank you Abbie!
LikeLike
I read The Coffin Trail several years ago, before I started reading book blogs. I don’t remember much about it except that I wasn’t impressed enough to carry on with the series. But I’ve seen so many good reviews of Edwards’ writing and this series that I probably should give it another chance.
Thanks for the reminder!
LikeLike
I think I appreciated this all the more as I hanker after the more traditional police procedurals which have fallen a little out of favour for those featuring shifting time-lines and different points of view etc. and I enjoyed the writing style very much indeed – I will definitely be reading the second book which I already have on my kindle.
LikeLike
I love when “skeletons, of the kind that hide in cupboards, are rattled.” You have tempted and teased, so I do want to know more. Thanks!
LikeLike
Haha thank you Laurel – I do like a book with plenty of those types of skeletons!
LikeLike
Now this sounds like something I could sink my teeth into. Must check out the series now!
LikeLike
I’m quite looking forward to making my way through this series as I feel they will be filed under ‘dependable reads’
LikeLike
I’ll be looking out for this series. New to me.
LikeLike
I have been dipping in and out of this series, and really should start at the beginning! Martin is a very good writer.
LikeLike