This historical true crime happened in 1871 in the Greenwich are of Victorian London. Poor Jane Coulson had been found in a terrible state with her face bashed in on a footpath by a policeman following his beat in the area. The girl was at last unidentified so extreme were her facial injuries and in the week or so that it took to discover who she was a few other girls, sadly of disrepute, were named as the victim. Eventually the truth was discovered but Jane Coulson didn’t, couldn’t, survive her injuries.
This is a well-researched book of a crime that I hadn’t come across before and doesn’t just concentrate on the police’s investigation into the murder but also the three trials the suspect underwent with the accompanying views of both the media and the local population at the time. With a sense of the place impeccably reconstructed for the reader as well as a detailed look at the various stages of the investigation and the trial I was absorbed by this reconstruction. With enough doubt to whether the right person had been arrested from the outset the author has pieced together the details including those that didn’t appear at the trial. Of course, after such a long period of time, there is little hard evidence to re-examine but that didn’t stop the author applying principles known today that were not at this time, being used to make a reasonable assessment of the case.
The author also captures the characters who make up the background to the story. From the reluctant witness of the shop-keeper who was unable to identify the man who bought the hammer which was the alleged weapon to the righteous Mr Henry Pook who defended the alleged perpetrator Edmund Pook, no relative. Edmund Pook was supported by his father a grandly named Ebenezer Pook along with his brother and other family members. The victim, Jane Coulson had worked as a maid of all work for this middle-class family and as a result we get to see how the Victorian class system operated at that time. Maids of all work were by far the most common servants of the time with middle-class families keeping one to do long hours as a status symbol as much as anything. The Pooks were not so well-off that Jane even had a pokey attic for a room, she actually shared with the victim’s cousin!
All in all a fascinating and immensely readable account of the crime, its investigation both into the identity of the victim and the murderer, the trials that followed and just as intriguingly the reaction of the public both on the streets and through the media of the day. In some ways this reaction was split along class lines but not entirely which in itself was interesting.
In the end my conclusion ties in with the authors but read the book yourself, you may well think that another scenario is equally as likely as to who did kill Jane Coulson.
I’d like to thank the publishers Head of Zeus who allowed me to read an advance copy of this book. This unbiased review is my thank you to them.
Published UK: 14 July 2016
Publisher: Head of Zeus
No of Pages 352
Genre: Historical True Crime
Amazon UK
Amazon US – Not Available
This does sound intriguing Cleo, especially as we get to play detective too! Interesting to consider the role of the media – still so relevant today.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do love the types of books that reflect what the media was saying at the time – it is hard sometimes (then as now) to work out whether popular views of the time sway the media or vice versus.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Another one to go in my TBR book (list no longer adequate!)
Just love true crime.
LikeLike
Haha I love that you have a book for your TBRs!! I’d not come across this crime before and the author handled both the research and the execution really well.
LikeLike
Thank you for this. Fantastic cover and what a wonderful name – Ebenezer Pook! I might squirrel that one away for future use.
LikeLike
Isn’t it a wonderful name?
LikeLike
What a fabulous title, and I do like the sound of the book. Another one for my watch-list!
LikeLike
Excellent news Jane!
LikeLike
Oh, Cleo, this really does sound fascinating! And I like it that the book concentrates not just on the crime, but also on the investigation and the trial. They’re all part of it, and to me, it’s fascinating to see how it’s done in different times and places.
LikeLike
It was fascinating Margot and by expanding the book beyond the crime itself gave the reader a good look at the reactions of those who the perpetrator and victim lived amongst.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Another tempting book to add to the list, Cleo! Thanks for sharing.
LikeLike
What a dramatic title and cover!
LikeLike
Why do crimes of these era always seem more shocking and gory? The dark streets and lack of known facts I guess. Fascinating all the same.
LikeLike
I suppose there were lots of ‘boring’ crimes at that time, as there are now, but the alleged motive for this one was very much of its time.
LikeLike
Ah, nothing like a bit of gory true crime to brighten up the day! Sounds good! 🙂
LikeLike
Haha I’ve struggled to really get sucked into anything much lately with so much going on and little time but I was keen to pick this one up – guess that says as much about me as the book 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nicely reviewed, Cleo. I enjoy reading historical fiction though I can’t say I have tried true historical crime fiction. This book does sound very good. There’s something appealing about Victorian London and crime.
LikeLike
I love true crime and haven’t heard of this one before.
sherry @ fundinmental
LikeLike