Posted in Book Review, Books I have read

The Thirteenth Coffin – Nigel McCrery

Crime Fiction 3*s
Crime Fiction
3*s

Flicking through NetGalley as I do on a far too regular basis I came across The Thirteenth Coffin, recognising the author’s name from the excellent non-fiction Silent Witnesses, an engaging read on the history of forensics, that I read a couple of years ago, I decided to try this fiction novel, the fourth featuring DCI Mark Lapslie.

Nothing whets my appetite when it comes to serial killers than one that has a novel method, motivation or detective. This book seemed to fit the bill, the police realise they may have a serial killer on their hands when on investigating the death of a tramp in an old disused Cold War Bunker the police find twelve coffins and twelve dolls – some of the dolls are in the coffin but not all. The dolls, made of papier-mache with wax heads seem to represent jobs or hobbies so there are among others a fireman, a teacher, a bride, a general and a nurse. It looks like someone wants twelve people dead. And then a bride is shot on her wedding day…

The investigation is underway by DCI Lapslie and his team which includes Emma Bradbury as they try to find a link between the victims past and present – the reader gets some insight from details about those who died earlier in excerpts that are given throughout the book. As a twist on the drunk and miserable detective Mark Lapslie is a man suffering from synaesthesia (the rare neurological condition that causes his brain to crosswire his senses), something which was initially interesting but I’m afraid I found the descriptions of voices as tastes and the logistics of communicating with his team broke the story up without adding a great deal in return.

The plotting was superb, I really liked the way the author took his inspiration from the mini coffins found at Arthur’s Seat in Edinburgh during the 19th century and used it to create a story which had a more credible than most motive for murder, one where for once all the victims weren’t beautiful young women. Unusually I cottoned onto this motive fairly early on in the book which took away some of the admiration of the detective’s deductive skills but there was still plenty of drama to keep me going until the end especially as that was only one piece of the jigsaw that needed completing.

I think this would make a great crime drama for TV; Nigel McCrery has written for many crime series on TV including Silent Witness and New Tricks but I’m not convinced that the protagonist translates as well onto the page, the sights and sounds would be much more effective with some dramatic music and other visual special effects with a spooky voice-over than being told that this man’s voice tastes like petrol or this person ’has a voice like soothing chamomile tea with honey’ An enjoyable enough crime thriller which despite the high body count didn’t have me wincing at endless descriptions of unnecessary violence but sadly not one that had me on the edge of my seat either.

The Thirteenth Coffin will be published on 31 December 2015 by Quercus books who were kind enough to allow me to read this book in return for my honest opinion.

Author:

A book lover who clearly has issues as obsessed with crime despite leading a respectable life

10 thoughts on “The Thirteenth Coffin – Nigel McCrery

  1. You make a really interesting point, Cleo, that some books translate very well onto the screen. And this one sounds as though it’s got the sort of visual context that would work very well on TV or film. Glad you enjoyed it.

  2. Hi Cleo,

    Thanks so much for introducing me to Nigel McCrery’s writing, although Of course I was a ‘Silent Witness’ and ‘New Tricks’ follower, without really giving too much thought to the behind the scenes cast.

    I can understand some of your reservations about the descriptive quality of the narrative, although I don’t tend to mind that too much. I also don’t mind that I may have worked out the end game quite early on in the proceedings, just so long as the ‘getting there’ continues to hold my interest and intrigue.

    I do appreciate your even and balanced review though, it definitely gives me a good flavour of what to expect from Nigel’s style of writing and narrative.

    I have decided that I am going to add the first book in the series to my want to read list, despite the fact that the individual stories would appear to work well as stand alone’s, if the ratings and reviews are to be believed.

    I hope that you enjoyed your Christmas celebrations 🙂

    Yvonne

      1. I start off with all good intentions, but tend to find myself coming in at the middle of a series more often than not these days, much to the irritation of some of my blogging friends 🙂

        This can cause issues if the protagonist has personal or professional issues which may affect the way they conduct a case and as the reader I am not privy to the special circumstances. However, I find that a good author will always find a way to work a short explanation into the storyline, which is enough for me to be going on with.

        Life is too short and there are just too many great books out there, to start every series at the beginning 🙂

  3. Thanks for sharing! This does sound quite interesting. Sorry it wasn’t the BEST overall, but it sounds like your issues weren’t enough to take away from most of the “enjoyment” if you will. It sounds weird to say enjoyment when it’s a murder mystery huh? haha

    -Lauren
    http://www.shootingstarsmag.blogspot.com

Leave a Reply, I love hearing what you have to say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s