Estelle Paradise woke up one morning to find baby Mia missing from her cot, not only that but her clothes, nappies and all the other paraphernalia that goes along with a small baby has disappeared too.
As the title doesn’t just beg comparisons, it actively behaves like a teenage cheerleader to make sure we don’t miss them, to the recent hit books in the psychological thriller/domestic noir genre of Gone Girl and Girl on the Train, it would be remiss of me not to comment on them; this definitely fits into the psychological thriller genre, there is an unreliable narrator and someone is missing! That said, this is actually a far more thoughtful book, dealing with postpartum psychosis although efforts have been made to create the tension and twists and turns required to match these books. More of that later…
We first meet Estelle when she is in a hospital bed following a car accident, oh and part of her ear is missing! She has police guards at the door and her husband Jack is firing questions at her about what has happened to baby Mia, there is just one problem, Estelle has amnesia and can’t remember.
The media goes wild when the news breaks that Estelle didn’t report Mia missing and the assumption is made that one or both parents are involved in her disappearance, after all, what other explanation could there be? Estelle is quickly packed off to psychiatric hospital to help recover her memory and vast swathes of the book are taken up with her sessions with Dr Ari and Estelle and Jack’s history told through flashbacks. What the public doesn’t know and the reader does is that Estelle struggled with motherhood and her biggest fear is that she did have something to do with Mia’s disappearance, and as such this is a fascinating look at postpartum psychosis. So to the characters: I was quite ok with not liking many of the characters, I did have some sympathy with Estelle especially as her history was revealed, but I found Jack lacked depth, if you want a portrayal of the most emotionally absent husband, this is your book.
So back to the twists and turns, despite a strong start I found these to get progressively more far-fetched and at that point I found this book harder to engage with. The biggest surprise is when we find out the solution to the mystery the book carries on for a considerable amount of time, this to me felt like overkill and is the part that made me decide that I won’t be recommending this one to other readers, simply it should have finished at what I consider to be the right time.
I was lucky enough to receive my copy of this book through Amazon Vine in return for my honest opinion. Little Girl Gone also appears to being published under the title Remember Mia, which to my mind is a far more appropriate title, and is due to be published today, 24 September 2015.
Love your cheerleader description – and I think the alternative title works well. When will this marketing ploy be over?
LikeLike
Not soon enough for me! I just think it sets the authors up for unfair comparisons – this book actually had a lot going for it but I felt that it had been moulded to fit!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I read an excellent short story recently with this very theme. It was haunting and oh so beautiful. It sounds like this book might have been better off edited to be shorter.
LikeLike
I felt so – it was just all went on too long for me – and got a little ridiculous.
LikeLike
I was put off from this book just by the copycat type title and your review has backed that up. Thanks for another full and great review Cleo.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you – I should have known better 😉
LikeLike
I had requested this book from NetGalley, and have not yet received it….and now I see that I already have the book under the name Remember Mia! I hate when that happens…LOL.
I haven’t read it yet, but I won’t be downloading it from NetGalley…how does one cancel a request?
I have heard some others remark on Little Girl Gone, and how it seemed far-fetched as well. Of course, I had already requested the book (and purchased Remember Mia).
However, it does sound like a pretty good story in parts. Thanks for sharing.
LikeLike
I don’t know that you can cancel requests – I’m glad that I’m not the only one to find it a bit far fetched – it was a shame because the beginning was actually good, as was the premise
LikeLike
Thanks, Cleo, as always, for your candor and your thoughtful review. I know exactly what you mean by plot twists that get progressively more far-fetched. They pull me right out of a book, too. And your ‘cheerleading’ comment – brilliant! No, I won’t be rushing out to get this one…
LikeLike
It’s such a shame but as soon as that little worm in my brain says ‘That isn’t realistic I lose connection with the book – I don’t recommend this one for you 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Warning well heeded, Cleo 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hmmm….your reaction is similar to another one I read recently. I think I already have this book on my Kindle under the US name. Guess I won’t rush to read it . Although the post-partum issues are interesting to me. And I am so ready for the words ‘gone’ and ‘girl’ to be out of favor.
LikeLike
Oh Kay – There were elements that I liked, such as the post-partum psychosis but it all went too far… Me too, it also gets very confusing with so many books with similar names!!
LikeLike
Here’s hoping your next read is better.
sherry @ fundinmental
LikeLike
Yay! Sooo not tempted!! Great review – the whole jumping on bandwagons thing is really annoying and this title just sounds like such a mash-up of so many other recent titles. I bet it was her publisher’s idea… but I bet it puts as many people off as it attracts.
LikeLike
Haha, didn’t think I could sell this one to you even if I gave it five stars! It is a shame about the title, the new one sounds much more in keeping with the subject matter too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry the twists were a bit much after awhile. I am quite curious about this one. I think the topic of post partum psychosis to be quite interesting.
-lauren
http://www.shootingstarsmag.blogspot.com
LikeLike
It is a fascinating subject, and one I am keen on which is why I chose to read this book and the parts about Estelle felt authentic, it was the solving of the mystery that went awry for me.
LikeLike
I have heard a lot about this book over Twitter now, but I couldn’t bring myself to quite like it. I am a huge Gone Girl fan, and I find this novel’s title a joke on the original Gone Girl… It is not working, publishers, it is not. Now that I read your review, I feel slightly better that my prejudices were not ill-founded.
LikeLike
Haha, I decided to overcome my dislike of the title because of the premise, post-partum difficulties is something I’m interested in but although it started well it seemed to evolve into something different and too far-fetched for this reader.
LikeLike
Have you read ‘The Yellow Wallpaper’ (if you’re interested in post-partum difficulties)?
LikeLike
No – I haven’t come across that one – off to check it out now, thank you 🙂
LikeLike
Cool! Please, let me know what you think if you read it 🙂
LikeLike