To avoid spoiling this book for anyone who hasn’t read I am unable to tell you very much about the plot at all as this is one of those books which needs to be discovered page by page.
Dr. Marc Schlosser, a GP is the narrator, our main protagonist and at the very beginning of the book we find out that he is about to face the Board of Medical Examiners. We know this is connected to the death of Ralph Meier, a famous actor and his wife is accusing the doctor of murder. The only thing we know what connects these two men is that the root of this death went back to a consultation by the doctor eighteen months previously.
The structure of the book takes us back from the present and builds up to a vacation taken at a Summer House with Swimming Pool then moves up the arc the other side back to the present. This works incredibly well, giving a feeling that Herman Koch is inviting the reader to make a judgment on the characters. The characters in this book are not as inherently as dislikeable as those in The Dinner but their actions are just as questionable, not least, our narrator Dr. Marc Shlosser whose thoughts on his patients alone made me wince (and make me wonder about my own doctor). However when we see Marc in a domestic setting, a different side of him shines through.
Herman Koch is exceptionally good at managing the pace in this book. I really needed to keep reading, I had to know what had happened to lead Marc to the Board of Medical Examiners and I desperately wanted to know what the outcome would be; but ultimately, this is a book about morality. What you as a reader find sympathy with and what you find abhorrent will potentially be different to my views. In my opinion this is one of the reasons why I liked reading this book, despite the feeling that this was almost a train crash in slow motion. I love the darkness to the writing, Marc’s views are imposed on the reader and these range from his patients, the arts, certain types of people and virtually anything that makes his life uncomfortable are astute if at times almost intolerably objectionable.
Like The Dinner it is hard for me to state I enjoyed this book, for the same types of reasons at times I had to squint at the page because as much I needed to know what happened next, I almost didn’t want to get drawn any further into the murky depths of horror, so much more repulsive for what wasn’t said.
I found myself thinking about Marc at odd times long after I’d left the book. If that isn’t the sign of a book that makes you think, question where you stand on the line of morality, I don’t know what is.
I’d like to thank the publishers Crown Publishing for a copy of this book prior to the publication date of 3 June 2014 in return for this honest review.
This sounds as compelling as The Dinner. I didn’t like anyone in it either, but couldn’t stop reading.
LikeLike
Yes Herman Koch has a real knack of making the reader engage with those that you can’t imagine doing so in real life!
LikeLike
Definitely sounds like a book to make you think. Interesting.
LikeLike
Definitely made me think, question and judge on every page… a great read!
LikeLike
GREAT REVIEW! Wow–I really can’t wait to get my hands on this one now! I think I’m #1 on the hold list at the library, so I’ll get my copy as soon as it’s released. I’ll be anxious to compare our reactions!
LikeLike
Thank you. I hope you have a great read , like The Dinner, I think ‘enjoy’ is the wrong word for this book. You were keen to be no. 1 on the list!
LikeLike
Another great review, Cleo! On the one hand, I want to read it even more now, but on the other, all this talk of darkness and horror has me a bit worried…
LikeLike
This is certainly not an explicit book with the darkness centering on morality as much as anything. I found some of the Doctors thoughts funny but they made me wince too! So hard to review this book as the whole plot has to unfold for each reader so not to spoil it!
LikeLike
Ah, that sounds good then! I worked with GPs for years and got used to a level of…shall we say…black humour from them, so that aspect intrigues me…
LikeLike
I haven’t read The Dinner, but it always sounded fascinating, as does this one!! I do want to check this out. 🙂
LikeLike
I think The Dinner was more shocking to read than this one but Herman Koch knows how to raise plenty of questions for his readers to answer!
LikeLike
I had the same reaction as you Cleo, I had to keep reading but wasn’t sure I liked the book. Still not sure! I haven’t read ‘The Dinner’ so didn’t know what to expect. SD
LikeLike
I have a galley of this book and am looking forward to reading it soon. Koch is a new author for me, so we’ll see how it goes!
LikeLike
Being sucked into a plot is one of the greatest adventures of reading.
LikeLike
It is brilliant and Herman Koch is fantastic at doing this but because everything is connected it made it very hard to write the review 😉
LikeLike